Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Spoken Thoughts

Welcome back, let's skip the foreplay and get to the point. 
The greatest threat to our way of life in the wake of this political assassination attempt in Arizona is not the perceived threat to the Second Amendment.  The Second Amendment isn't going anywhere.  Get used to it, hippies, guns are here to stay.  Like it or not.  It is for countless reasons that I neither fear nor celebrate the attack on this American freedom, considered sacrosanct by some and archaic by others.  But the main reason I don't take a distinct side on it is because it doesn't matter.  Reform the policy but preserve the liberty.  Right...like that's ever gonna happen.  Anyway, we face a far greater threat that demands my immediate ranting...err...I mean attention.   My immediate attention

We have a passionate political discourse in this country.  We always have.  We have nuts from both the right and left inciting hate speech and extremism.  We have a culture of violence.  Notice the syntax.  Not specifically 'political' violence, just violence.  Violence of all kinds.  I wouldn't be surprised to learn that we are virtually alone in our love of "torture porn" movies like Saw and Hostel.  I think it's a little to real to the rest of the world.  But for us, it's entertainment.  We like to watch things die.  Slowly.  And often. 

We step into dangerous territory when we confuse this simple verbage.  It's easy to say we're politcally violent.  It may even be slightly accurate, but it's far too shortsighted.  That's like saying Africa has a small AIDs problem.  All but one word in the sentence is completely accurate:  small.  Let's apply that same logic to the following sentence:  America is politically violent.  All but one word is completely accurate.  Guess which one?  Exactly!  So let's call a spade a spade, not a 'darkish, pointy, round thing that's vertically challenged'.  Let us strive for accuracy in our syntax.  Especially when discussing such delicate issues. 

Faulty or innacurate syntax can be dangerous.  That childhood rhyme "sticks and stones can break my bones, but words can never hurt me" - that's total crap.  Toss that one in the Santa Claus-Toothfaily-and-other-lies-we-tell-our-children pile. 

Words can hurt a lot when those words pose a danger to our ability to use whatever words we choose.  Seems like a contradiction, and it may be, but so may be slander lawsuits and gag orders in a country with free speech.  We'll save that one for another day. 

We have enough contradictions that already embattle and restrict our First Amendment, and the more we push to limit the political hate speech and rhetoric that some people falsely see as responsible for the attempted murder of a genuine public servant, the less freedom we will have when this debate subsides and this day is long forgotten. 

I've never before understood how people make the parallel between liberalism and facism.  The past few days have brought me amazing clarity on how volatile the line between protection and restriction is.  Enforcing limitations upon political discourse will protect no one.  Instead it will harm everyone in ways we cannot see when we are blinded by reaction. 

I don't like Glenn Beck.  Or Sean Hannity.  Or Rush Limbaugh, or Bill O'Reilly, or...what?  wait, that can't be.  Surely you jest.  Chris Matthews?  Really?  Yes, him too.  Or anyone else that tries to present their opinion as if it's news.  Except maybe people who are funny about it, like Jon Stewart.  Everyone else can shut the hell up until they have facts to report.  Fox news can't seem to tell the difference, so they are invited to shut the hell up forever. 

As much as I'd like these people to be removed from the public discourse, along with a looooooong list of others, even assholes and morons have the right to speak freely to anyone willing to listen.  They have that right because we live in the US of A, and if you take away free speech will just be a big shithole of a country that can't educate it's kids or pay it's bills.  Yes, the line is that thin these days. 

So I encourage you to make this change, America.  This one little change.  Hell, you can even replace one of you many already-defunct New Year's Resolutions with this easy-to-attain goal: 

If you don't like it, don't participate in it, listen to it, or watch it. 

Make that decision anywhere that you can.  We can't always choose what our tax dollars do, but we sure as hell can decide what our radio's, televisions, and expendable dollars do.  Stop yelling at the TV, and stop letting the TV yell at you.  Change the fucking channel.  Just don't you dare tell anyone they can't talk.  Free Speech is the one thing that makes me say about America that line that the wealthy and white have been using for oh so long:  "Love it, or leave it".  It is not subject to change, nor should it be.

Thanks again for reading, or if it's your first time then what took you so long?  Agree or disagree, turn off the TV and think. 

2 comments:

  1. Well this doesn't affect your argument in any way really but so called "torture porn" is not unique to American culture. The Italians and even the French have had an affinity for twisted cinema violence for decades.
    More to your point though, I agree that hate speech has been alive and well in this country since it's founding. The difference now is that media outlets are in our face where ever we go and the distortions are spread at warp speed. For the most part I do personally choose to change the channel and find my news from factually grounded sources.
    I guess what bothers me most of all are the opinions of people I meet on a daily basis that feel the need to regurgitate that misinformation in my direction. Mostly these days I just smile and nod.
    So at this point I've lost my faith in our corporate controlled two party system. Calling back to your previous post stating the facts about our society's obvious ills, I believe we are on an unavoidable crash course. No governmental shift is really going to stop the locomotive of corporate domination in our lives. To me it's pretty clear that this way of life is ultimately unsastainable and I'm pretty sure that our ancestors are going to look back at the early 21st century and wonder what the hell we were thinking.
    I'm struggling not to be a doomsday theorist or anything but with my recent interest in ancient civilizations and coorelating that knowledge to current day my obsessive nature has steered me into my newest hobby which is survival planning. Having access to rural land and shelter it just seems like the natural thing to do. Hopefully it will just remain a hobby for the better part of my existence but should we ever be forced to revert to a hunter/gatherer society, I'll have a leg up.
    In the mean time I'll continue to do what Americans do best which is consume. From television and film, to food and more food I will enjoy the fruits of our culture with my friends and family with seemingly blissful ignorance but in the shadows I will be researching and preparing.
    How's that for thoughts on thoughts? Been wanting to comment on your blog and that's what came out I guess. Keep up the good work.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Well said, sir, and thanks for the information regarding the 'torture porn' craze. I especially like the comment " I'm pretty sure that our ancestors are going to look back at the early 21st century and wonder what the hell we were thinking."

    As for the survival skills, I've always felt planning for the worst and hoping for the best is a wise course of action. And while I do believe we will pretty much always have access to cities and electricity, etc, I don't necessarily believe that we will always be willing to pay the price for them (i.e. becoming an indentured servant to corp. america). There's no reason to reduce or deny your own freedom of choice.

    This kind of commentary is what I was hoping for. Big thanks for reading, and an even bigger thanks for thinking.

    ReplyDelete